Contact

As you may have already read elsewhere on our site, Erica Boll Insurance has been a fixture in eastern Wisconsin for quite a while. While we are located in New Holstein, our agency serves individuals, families, and businesses throughout all of Calumet and surrounding Counties.

Address

1806 Wisconsin Ave.
New Holstein, WI 53061

Phone

Phone: 920-898-5781
Toll Free: 800-758-2116

Fax

Fax: 866-898-5998

Email

General Email Address: erica@boll-ins.com

Hours of Operation

Monday – Thursday: 9:00 – 5:00
Friday: 9:00 – 3:00
Saturday and Evening Hours by Appointment

Map

Get Directions

From

Add Waypoint

For

show options hide options

Avoid Tolls Avoid Highways Avoid Ferries

Excellent

Erica Boll Insurance

5.0

Based on 23 reviews

See all reviews

review us on

Bill B.

Always cheerful, friendly, informative & helpful! Great combination. Thank you Erica and staff!

Response from the owner: Thank you, Bill, for taking the time to post your review. I greatly appreciate your business!

Steve S.

The team ( girls ) always knock themselves. Out to help ! Thanks

Response from the owner: Thank you, Steve! We appreciate your comments. Have a great day!

Cherri W.

Erica and Michelle are so helpful and knowledgeable. I can always talk to them or they will get back to me, quickly.

Response from the owner: Thank you Cherri. We appreciate the comments. Happy New Year!

Paul B.

Erica is second generation and just as reliable as her father. She always looks out for her clients. She's special

Response from the owner: Thank you Paul! I did learn from the best, as dad always said, customers come first and do right by them!

Hannah F.

The best customer service, Erica always helps get the best deals on insurance and truly cares about each of her clients.

Response from the owner: Thank you, Hannah!

Kerri B.

Erica is someone I know I can trust to provide great advice on our insurance needs. Her and Michelle always take such great care of us!

Carol R.

Erica Boll and her agency are a delight to do business with. They are friendly, professional, competitive in price, and we like using local businesses whenever possible. I would highly recommend her to anyone!!! Thank you Erica!!!

Response from the owner: Thank you Carol! I hope you and Tom are well and can spend some time this summer in Wisconsin. Take Care!

Henry M.

Courteous & Friendly personalized service.

Response from the owner: Hello Henry, Thank you for your review. I hope you are well!

Sarah V.

I LOVE the personalized service that we get from Boll Insurance! I can call with questions about coverage and procedures and they are always happy and willing to help!

Robin L.

Great service. Friendly staff.

Lori Van P.

Erica is super easy to work with. Her email responses were always timely, she knows when a phone call is appropriate and no creepy sales pitches to sell us more than we need. Rates were also the lowest with premium coverage. Thank you for the exceptional customer service!

Jamie N.

I've worked with Erica for more than 20 years and her professionalism and customer service has been second to none. She is always willing to look at what's best for us, her client(s), and I've appreciated her insight in providing us the best overall options. I'd highly recommend working with her!